A Bronx ex-convict was killed by police gunfire early yesterday in an
incident that was immediately followed by tense disagreement between
the man's family and police over what happened. Carleton Lockhart, 32,
was shot once in the left shoulder and once in the abdomen by two
uniformed officers from the 46th precinct, who confronted him on West
179th Street near University Avenue, said Insp. Michael Coan, a police
spokesman. Lockhart died of his wounds at St. Barnabas Hospital Center. A few minutes before midnight, Lockhart was standing on
the street with a small group of men, arguing with one of them over the
ownership of a cellphone;on that everyone agreed. What happened next
was portrayed by police as the pursuit of a possibly armed suspect by
two police units happening upon a volley of bullets. But a friend of
the victim's who said he witnessed the incident, and the family's
attorney, both called the killing an injustice. Police said Lockhart
pistol-whipped and then fired three shots at an 18-year-old man with
whom he had been arguing. The man later told police at the 46th
precinct stationhouse that Lockhart fired at him, according to a police
source. "I can't believe he missed me," the source quoted the man as
saying, adding that three witnesses corroborated the man's account. One of
the officers tackled Lockhart to a wall before firing a round, while
the other officer fired two rounds, police said. It was not clear
yesterday which bullets struck the victim. Several neighbors who
witnessed yesterday's shooting gave different accounts. One man, who
declined to identify himself, insisted that Lockhart was not armed.
Another witness, Oscar Ortiz, 26, said he saw from his window on West
179th Stret that more than two officers fired their weapons at
Lockhart, who cried for them to stop. The family's attorney, William Ferro, said
the facts did not add up. [more] and [more]