Prosecutors Thursday announced they
will not file criminal charges against a city police officer who was
videotaped pummeling a car-theft suspect with a metal flashlight, a
case that critics compared to the racially charged Rodney King beating.
The decision was denounced by minority community leaders and Mayor
James Hahn, who said, "I do not agree with that decision. I saw what
you saw." After a five-month review, the Los Angeles County district
attorney's office concluded that there wasn't sufficient evidence to
bring charges against Officer John Hatfield, who struck suspect Stanley
Miller 11 times with a 2-pound steel flashlight after a June 23
car-and-foot chase in South Los Angeles. "In light of the totality of
the circumstances facing Officer Hatfield, we cannot establish beyond a
reasonable doubt that Officer Hatfield's actions were without legal
necessity," Deputy District Attorney Margo Baxter said in a statement.
Miller, who is black, was beaten on the ground after he appeared to
surrender. The district attorney's decision "points out the
regretable reality that all too often in this community we have to deal
with a double standard in justice," said John Mack, president of the
Los Angeles Urban League, who has been monitoring the case for the
mayor. Prosecutors had been reviewing the case since Aug. 20, when the
Police Department turned over the results of its investigation into the
beating. Police Chief William Bratton did not make a recommendation on whether criminal charges should be
filed. Miller, who turns 37 on Friday, filed a $25 million claim
against the city, saying he suffered brain damage and other injuries in
the arrest. [more] and [more]
Minister Tony
Muhammad, western regional director of the Nation of Islam, said the
decision sends a "dangerous signal ... that black life, brown life have
no value." [more]